Open RFP

Request for Proposals: External Evaluator - Title III Strengthening Institutions Program Grant

Description: 1. Purpose Eastern Iowa Community Colleges (EICC) seeks an independent External Evaluator for its five-year Strengthening Institutions Program (SIP, Title III Part A) project, Building Readiness through Innovative Technology Education (B.R.I.T.E.). The evaluator will provide continuous formative evaluation in Years 1-5, a mid-grant assessment at the end of Year 3, and a final summative report submitted with the Year 5 annual performance report to the U.S. Department of Education (ED). EICC is a public community college district founded in 1965 and accredited by the Higher Learning Commission. Its three campuses operate 17 facilities along a 120-mile Mississippi River corridor serving Clinton, Jackson, Muscatine, and Scott counties and parts of Cedar and Louisa counties. In fiscal 2025 EICC served 11,468 credit students and 14,119 continuing education students (6,353 FTE), with a 54.4% Pell award rate and roughly 30% minority enrollment. This RFP describes the project, the scope of evaluation services, required qualifications, proposal requirements, and how proposals will be scored. 2. Project Background B.R.I.T.E. responds to gaps identified in EICC's 2024 HLC reaccreditation self-study and 2025-29 Strategic Plan: AI absent from curriculum and career services, fragmented professional development, reactive student supports, and no institutional AI governance. In response, the project is built on three core structures: a new centralized Center for Teaching & Learning (CTL), AI integration within EICC's divisional student services model, and a formal AI policy and governance process. It is organized around six Comprehensive Development Plan (CDP) goals along a five-year arc: Foundation in Year 1, Build and Pilot in Years 2-3, and Embed and Sustain in Years 4-5. The CDP Goals and proposed activities include: Goal Focus Key Grant Activities 1 AI in curriculum and career pathways AI Literacy ILO; Champions of Change faculty pilots across 16 Guided Pathways; district-wide curriculum embed 2 AI Programming A.A.S. and stackable A.A.S. fidelity monitoring; Student Data Center Laboratory; 14-week credential Workforce Pell-eligible Generative AI credential; laptop loaner program 3 AI-enhanced student support services AI-enhanced advising, early alert, and tutoring within Element 451 CRM; industry mentoring platform; career navigation 4 Center for Teaching & Learning CTL launch and charter; change management framework; faculty PD cohorts 5 AI policy and governance Board-adopted AI Acceptable Use Policy (Year 2); tool adoption standards; compliance training 6 Industry collaboration and workforce Advisory Council feedback loop; credential co-design; mentor alignment recruitment; corporate PD modules 3. Scope of Work The evaluator will independently assess implementation fidelity, progress toward activity objectives, and achievement of CDP goals and required SIP performance measures. Internal evaluation is led by the Vice Chancellor of Academic Affairs (Project Director) with the Project Coordinator, who collect project data and establish pre-grant baselines. The external evaluator oversees data quality and verifies that collection procedures are applied with fidelity. The services below are the minimum required by EICC's approved grant application. Proposers may suggest optional services, priced separately. Data quality oversight (Years 1-5) • Review the internal team's data collection instruments and procedures, including the AI element of the Information Literacy rubric, and verify that they are applied with fidelity. • Review the pre-grant baselines the internal team establishes in Year 1. Formative evaluation (Years 1-5) • Conduct annual site visits to assess implementation fidelity and progress toward activity objectives. EICC expects at least one in-person visit per year; timing and locations will be set with the Project Director. • Review project data, including Activity Director reports and platform analytics, against the approved milestone timeline. • Serve as a member of the Internal Monitoring Team (IMT) and attend its meetings: monthly in Year 1, quarterly thereafter (virtual attendance acceptable). • Deliver an annual written formative report with findings and actionable recommendations. EICC will respond to findings in the following quarter. Mid-grant assessment (end of Year 3) • Assess progress against CDP goals, KPIs, and required SIP measures; recommend adjustments to the Years 4-5 implementation plan. Summative evaluation (Year 5) • Produce a final report on the extent to which B.R.I.T.E. achieved its CDP goals, activity objectives, and required SIP performance measures, suitable for submission to ED with the Year 5 annual performance report. Reporting support • Collaborate with the Project Coordinator on required ED performance reports by providing evaluation data and narrative. • Present annually to the Board of Trustees with the Chancellor. 4. Performance Measures The evaluator will assess the student KPIs and required SIP measures below, plus the short-term activity indicators for each CDP goal (Section C of the funded application, available to the selected evaluator). Student key performance indicators Goals Measure Data source Target 1, 2, 3 Year-to-year Fall-to-fall retention tracking 7% increase by end of Year 5 retention Goals Measure Data source Target 1, 2, 3 Completion Degree/credential attainment, 2% increase overall by end of Year 5; 75% overall and AI cohorts completion for new AI program students 1, 2, 3, 6 AI workforce AI element of Information 100% of enrolled students assessed; 80% score readiness Literacy rubric; targeted AI skills 3+ on 4-point scale; 95% of AI program assessment completers show mastery 2, 3, 6 AI student Post-completion tracking of 95% of participants tracked; 80% employed in placement A.A.S. and related cohorts degree field Required SIP Performance Measures Measure Data source % change in full-time, degree-seeking undergraduate IPEDS; annual comparison to baseline enrollment % of first-time, full-time students still enrolled in year two Colleague SIS cohort analysis % graduating within three years of enrollment IPEDS; institutional SIS Median yearly income of graduates Iowa Workforce Development wage matching; follow-up surveys Activity indicators include faculty participation in AI PD and pilots, courses embedding the AI Literacy ILO, A.A.S. persistence, credential approval status, student use of AI-enhanced advising and tutoring, mentoring enrollment, policy adoption and compliance training rates, and Advisory Council engagement. 5. Deliverables and Timeline The contract covers all five years of the grant, with a final report due at grant close. Deliverable Timing Audience Data quality and baseline review Year 1, then ongoing; findings Project Director, IMT included in each annual formative report IMT meeting participation Monthly in Year 1; quarterly IMT Years 2-5 Annual site visit (at least one in person) Once per year, Years 1-5 Project staff, stakeholders Annual formative report with recommendations Each project year, in time for Project Director, IMT, Board the ED annual performance report Evaluation input to ED annual performance reports As required by ED Project Coordinator Annual Board of Trustees presentation Once per year Board of Trustees Mid-grant evaluation report End of Year 3 Project Director, IMT Final summative evaluation report Year 5, with the final ED, Board of Trustees performance report 6. Qualifications The evaluator must be independent of EICC: no current employment, governance role, or financial interest in EICC or any B.R.I.T.E. vendor or contractor. Conflict of Interest. Proposers must be independent of EICC and must disclose in their proposal any current or prior employment, contract, governance role, or financial or personal relationship with EICC, its employees, or any B.R.I.T.E. vendor or contractor. Any individual or firm that assisted in preparing EICC's B.R.I.T.E. grant application or this RFP is not eligible to submit a proposal (2 CFR 200.319(b)). EICC will determine whether a disclosed relationship creates a real or apparent conflict of interest and may disqualify a proposer on that basis. The selected evaluator must notify the Project Director in writing within five business days of any conflict that arises during the contract term. No EICC employee, officer, or agent with a real or apparent conflict of interest involving a proposer will participate in evaluating proposals or awarding the contract (2 CFR 200.318(c)). Minimum qualifications • Lead evaluator holds a master's degree or higher in evaluation, education research, social science, or a related field. • At least five years of experience evaluating federally funded postsecondary programs. • Prior external evaluation of at least one Title III or Title V (SIP, Developing HSI, or similar) grant. • Experience with mixed-methods design and with IPEDS, student information system, and retention/completion data. • Working knowledge of ED performance reporting and 2 CFR Part 200. Preferred qualifications • Community college evaluation experience, especially multi-campus districts. • Experience evaluating AI, educational technology, faculty development, or CTL initiatives. • Familiarity with the U.S. Department of Labor AI Literacy Framework, Guided Pathways, and workforce credential outcomes (including Workforce Pell). 7. Proposal Requirements Proposals may not exceed 15 pages, excluding résumés, references, and the cost proposal. Use 11-point font or larger and submit as a single PDF. 8. Cover letter signed by an authorized representative, with contact information, UEI number, and confirmation of active SAM.gov registration. 9. Firm or individual profile, including an independence statement and the conflict-of-interest disclosures required in Section 6. 10. Evaluation approach: proposed design, methods, data sources, and how formative findings will drive course correction across the six CDP goals. 11. Work plan and timeline aligned to the deliverables in Section 5. 12. Staffing: lead evaluator and team members, roles, time commitment, and résumés. 13. Relevant experience: at least two Title III/Title V or comparable federal evaluations, with outcomes and sample report excerpts (redacted as needed). 14. References: three clients from the past five years, at least one a community college. 15. Cost proposal: annual and five-year total for the minimum services in Section 3, itemized by personnel, travel, and other direct costs, as a fixed fee per year or a not-to-exceed hourly rate. The annual cost of these services may not exceed $21,600. Price any optional services separately. 16. Evaluation Criteria A review committee appointed by the Project Director will score proposals out of 100 points. EICC may interview the top-ranked proposers before final selection. Criterion Points Qualifications and Title III/Title V evaluation experience 30 Quality and rigor of evaluation approach 25 Understanding of B.R.I.T.E. goals and community college context 15 Cost reasonableness and value 15 Work plan feasibility and staffing capacity 10 References 5 Total 100 9. Schedule, Submission, and Contract Terms Procurement schedule Milestone Date RFP released Tuesday, November 10, 2026 Intent to apply with any written questions due Friday, November 20, 2026 Answers posted to all proposers Monday, November 30, 2026 Proposals due Monday, December 7, 2026, 2 p.m. CT Interviews (if needed) December 16-17, 2026 Selection and notice of award Monday, December 21, 2026 Contract start Monday, January 4, 2027 Submission. Email one PDF to Shellie Thalacker, Senior Executive Assistant to the Vice Chancellor for Academic Affairs at sjthalacker@eicc.edu with the subject line "B.R.I.T.E. External Evaluator RFP." Submit questions in writing only and to the same contact; answers will be shared with all entities indicating intent to apply. Late proposals will not be considered. Contract terms • Initial term covers Year 1, renewable annually through Year 5 based on satisfactory performance and continued federal funding. • The annual budget for the minimum evaluation services may not exceed $21,600, subject to ED approval. • Procurement follows EICC purchasing policy and federal standards at 2 CFR 200.317-200.327. • The contractor must not be suspended or debarred (verified in SAM.gov) and must certify compliance with anti-lobbying requirements where applicable. • The contractor must comply with FERPA, sign a data-sharing agreement, and protect all student-level data. • Records must be retained for three years after the final expenditure report (2 CFR 200.334) and made available to EICC, ED, and auditors. • EICC may terminate for cause or convenience with written notice. • Evaluation reports and data become property of EICC; the contractor may publish findings only with EICC's written approval. • EICC reserves the right to reject any or all proposals, waive minor irregularities, and negotiate with the selected proposer. EICC is an equal opportunity institution.

Buyer
Department of Education

Federal · DC, US

Released
Nov 10, 2026
Closes
Dec 7, 2026(20 days left)
See your top accountsScan your site in seconds. Starbridge identifies your ICP and surfaces emerging opportunities from board meetings, job changes, new grants, contract expirations, RFPs, and more.
See your top 10 accounts