Proposals due by: December 1, 2026, at 5:00 p.m. Pacific Time
Submit proposals and all questions to:
Jessica Wigle, Director of Finance
jwigle@penmetparks.org
1. OVERVIEW AND PURPOSE
Peninsula Metropolitan Park District ("PenMet Parks" or "District") seeks proposals from qualified, independent forensic accounting firms to examine the financial and operational records of Stutsman Enterprise, Inc. ("Stutsman"), operator of the District-owned Madrona Links Golf Course in Gig Harbor, Washington. The engagement has three interrelated objectives: (a) verify gross greens-fee revenues and the percentage rent payable to the District; (b) determine Stutsman's actual and normalized profitability and the disposition of cash generated by the operation; and (c) evaluate expenditures and financial records relevant to the contractual duties to maintain, repair, and improve the golf course.
The District is concerned about the condition and maintenance of the golf course and seeks an objective examination of whether revenues were accurately reported, whether rental and capital-improvement obligations were met, what profits Stutsman earned, and whether expenditures on golf course maintenance and improvements were sufficient and properly documented. The consultant will provide fact-based findings and calculations, not predetermined conclusions.
The project may support pending litigation in Pierce County Superior Court. Consulting-expert and potential testifying-expert assignments will be directed and authorized separately by PenMet Parks and its counsel as described below.
2. DISTRICT AND CONTRACTUAL BACKGROUND
PenMet Parks provides public parks, facilities, and recreational programs to the Gig Harbor peninsula and nearby Pierce County communities serving a population of approximately 40,000 residents. Our mission is to enhance the quality of life by providing parks and recreation opportunities for our community. Our vision is to be a leader in promoting health and well-being in a thriving community. The Madrona Links Golf Course was originally owned by the City of Tacoma. In 1977, the City leased the property to what became Tyson Limited Partnership ("Tyson") pursuant to the Master Lease. The City subsequently sold the property and assigned the Master Lease to PenMet Parks. In 2014, Tyson subleased the golf course operation to Stutsman pursuant to the Stutsman Sublease. PenMet Parks terminated Tyson for breach of the Master Lease and exercised its right to continue the existing Stutsman Sublease. The Tyson Master Lease and its subsequent amendments provided that Tyson would pay PenMet Parks a percentage of the gross greens fees as rent. The Stutsman Sublease separately requires Stutsman to pay a percentage of the gross greens fees as rent. Both the Master Lease and the Sublease require the tenants to keep and maintain the golf course in good condition and repair, make capital improvements and operate the golf course in an efficient, high quality and reputable manner, and use tenant's best efforts to operate the golf course in a manner which will enhance the reputation and attractiveness of the golf course, pro shop and restaurant.
3. ENGAGEMENT OBJECTIVES AND DEFINITIONS
Review Period. Beginning January 2014 (to the extent reasonably reliable records are available) through to the present. The consultant will assess historical data availability and propose risk-based testing for the full period and intensive testing for selected years, subject to District approval.
Greens-fee revenues. Amounts included within the applicable contractual definitions, with separate analysis of fees charged, cash received, credit sales, refunds, memberships/passes, and other consideration for playing golf.
Profitability. Gross profit, operating income, EBITDA (where meaningful), net income, cash flow, owner economic benefits, and normalized economic profit, with explicit reconciliation among measures and explanation of assumptions.
Capital improvements. Expenditures properly qualifying as capital improvements to the golf course facilities under the contract and a stated accounting methodology; distinguish from routine maintenance, ordinary repairs, inventory, financing, and unsubstantiated transfers.
Contract interpretation. The District, through counsel, will provide controlling legal assumptions, including rental percentages, enforceable obligations, and treatment of disputed contractual issues. The consultant must identify the material effect of any alternative assumptions requested by counsel.
4. SCOPE OF WORK
Phase I - Contractual And Financial Mapping; Records Preservation; Audit Plan
A. Conduct an entrance conference with designated District staff and counsel to establish objectives, reporting lines, timing, litigation status, current record access, document preservation, and work priorities.
B. Prepare a contract and obligations matrix covering the master lease, amendments, 2014 sublease, applicable percentages, payment dates, annual improvement obligations, reporting rights, and relevant periods. Identify legal assumptions that require instructions from District counsel.
C. Map the legal entities, ownership and management structure, identify all operators, related entities and principals and key third parties associated with the golf course, cart rentals, pro shop, food and beverage, events and tournaments, instruction, equipment leases, memberships, and maintenance and operations.
D. Identify accounting systems, bank and merchant accounts, payment processors, booking/POS systems, golf-related revenue streams, and significant related-party transactions.
E. Develop a written work plan, document request list, data collection and interview plan, preliminary fraud-risk assessment, sampling strategy, and phased budget. Indicate which records are available directly under the contracts and which require voluntary cooperation, court process, or other authorization.
F. Assess system changes and historical data availability, including native exports, transaction detail, audit logs, overwritten data, and record-retention practices. Identify the earliest feasible testing periods and material limitations.
G. Identify circumstances requiring immediate preservation requests, and promptly report material obstacles to the District and its counsel.
H. Maintain a defensible record of evidence received, source, date, custodian, handling, transformations, and disposition.
Phase II - Gross Greens-Fee Reconstruction And Rent Reconciliation
A. Obtain and reconcile general ledgers, financial statements, budgets, forecasts, tax filings, bank statements, canceled checks, deposit records, credit-card records, merchant-processor settlements, cash logs, journal entries, subledgers, and any other relevant documentation.
B. Trace selected transactions from source documents through authorization, recording, settlement, bank activity, and financial reporting, and from the ledger back to underlying evidence.
C. Perform risk-based and targeted testing of cash receipts, disbursements, payroll, reimbursements, purchasing, inventory, fixed assets, debt, leases, prepaid items, receivables, payables, and manual journal entries.
D. Analyze transaction populations for duplicates, gaps, round-dollar entries, unusual timing, split purchases, weekend or after-hours activity, sequential invoices, altered payees, dormant or new vendors, payments just below approval limits, unusual refunds or voids, negative sales, transactions involving employees or related parties, and potential personal or nonbusiness use.
E. Obtain and analyze tee sheets, reservations, actual rounds played, POS transaction details and audit trails, rate tables, memberships, punch cards, tournament and outing records, complimentary play, refunds, canceled/deleted rounds and gift cards.
F. Compare tee-sheet reservations, check-ins, rates, rounds, cart assignments, cash drawer activity, point-of-sale records, online bookings, promotions, refunds, and deposits.
G. Test memberships, annual passes, punch cards, reciprocal privileges, complimentary access, discounts, credits, cancellations, and deferred revenue.
H. Review event and tournament payments and purchases.
I. Reconstruct greens-fee sales from independent operational records, not merely from accounting summaries supplied by the operator. Conduct bidirectional tracing from golfer/tee-time activity to charges and deposits, and from reported revenue back to operational source data.
J. Distinguish gross greens-fee charges, fees actually received, credit sales uncollected, refunds, discounts, chargebacks, deferred revenue, and other adjustments. Evaluate possible misclassification of golf consideration as food/beverage, membership, tournament, cart, instruction, or other revenue, consistent with contract definitions furnished by District counsel.
K. Perform analytics for missing transactions, altered sales, voids/refunds, override permissions, cash shortfalls, anomalies by shift or employee, rate changes, unaccounted rounds, and differences between tee-sheet, POS, general ledger, sales tax, and merchant data. Test selected anomalies against original documents.
L. Prepare an annual schedule showing reported and reconstructed greens-fee bases, contractual rent percentages applicable under counsel's instructions, rent due, rent paid to Tyson and PenMet, and quantified underpayments or overpayments. Identify unsupported estimates separately from verified transactions.
Phase III - Complete Operating Results, Owner Benefits And Reasonable-Profit
A. Reconstruct annual financial results for the entire golf course business, including greens fees, pro shop, cart rentals, food and beverage, tournaments, lessons, memberships, and other relevant operations. Reconcile income statements to general ledgers, tax returns, bank accounts, balance sheets, cash flows, and any monthly reports.
B. Evaluate all material expenses, including groundskeeping, irrigation, equipment, supplies, payroll, contractor charges, utilities, rent, administrative overhead, insurance, repairs, and depreciation; test reasonableness and proper period classification. Analyze accounting policy changes and adjustments that materially affect profit.
C. Identify owner compensation, distributions, dividends, management fees, related-party rents/charges, payments to affiliated businesses, personal or nonbusiness expenses, loans to/from owners, and transfers of cash or assets. Determine whether costs were paid at commercially supportable rates and prepare normalized results excluding unsupported, duplicative, or nonoperating items.
D. Test payroll and contractor payments against personnel files, time records, schedules, rates, approvals, tax forms, benefit deductions, and bank information; identify duplicate identities, ghost employees, unauthorized overtime, or conflicts.
E. Calculate and clearly distinguish operating profit, EBITDA, net income, free cash flow, cash distributed to owners, and total economic benefit to owners, with reconciliation to reported results. Analyze cumulative profits and distributions over the Review Period.
F. Provide annual and cumulative calculations of (i) operating cash generated, (ii) maintenance expenditures, (iii) capital improvements, (iv) owner/affiliate distributions or benefits, and (v) funds retained. Explain whether the financial evidence indicates available resources potentially relevant to deferred maintenance, without purporting to make the ultimate legal determination of required reinvestment.
Phase IV - Maintenance, Repair, And Capital-Improvement Compliance
A. Analyze compliance with capital improvement obligations: identify actual qualifying capital improvements completed and documented for each year; quantify any annual shortfall or excess. Do not presume that an annual excess may be carried forward or offset without District counsel's direction.
B. Review invoices, contracts, purchase orders, canceled checks, payment records, fixed-asset registers, general-ledger accounts, work orders, permits, project schedules, and photographic/physical evidence to verify whether claimed projects were actually performed, paid for, capital in nature, and attributable to the appropriate premises and year.
C. Identify any expenses coded as capital improvements that are routine maintenance, ordinary repairs, unrelated purchases, or unsupported; and any genuine improvements improperly expensed. Address the effect of differences between accounting capitalization rules and the contractual meaning of capital improvements.
D. Analyze maintenance and repair expenditures, staffing levels, maintenance programs, inspection and equipment logs, preventive maintenance, irrigation/water use, turf care, fertilizer/chemical costs, bunker maintenance, greens/tees/fairways, drainage, and equipment replacement, to the extent relevant and available.
E. Produce an integrated annual schedule showing reconstructed revenue, operating profits, maintenance spending, required capital improvements, documented qualifying improvements, any shortfall, and owner economic benefits, with assumptions and supporting exhibits.
Phase V - Interviews, Corroboration, And Additional Investigation
A. As authorized by the District and counsel, interview current/former operating, accounting, maintenance, and supervisory personnel, vendors, and other persons with direct knowledge of revenue recording, expenses, improvements, and operating practices.
B. Corroborate material statements using contemporaneous records, system metadata, independent third-party information, physical observations, and other lawful evidence. Record significant inconsistent statements and unsupported assertions.
C. Seek bank, processor, vendor, or other third-party confirmations only with appropriate authorization; do not contact potentially represented persons or opposing parties without prior approval from District counsel.
D. Recommend and price expanded procedures if evidence suggests fraud, concealed revenue, improper related-party transactions, altered records, or other material irregularity. Additional work requires written approval before performance.
5. DELIVERABLES AND REPORTING
A. Planning Memorandum. Within a mutually agreed period after notice to proceed: final methodology, contract matrix, risk assessment, document request schedule, staffing, detailed milestones, and phase-by-phase not-to-exceed budgets. Clearly identify unresolved legal assumptions and anticipated record limitations.
B. Interim Status Memoranda. Provide written updates at least monthly or at material decision points, describing records received, procedures completed, preliminary anomalies, budget status, anticipated impediments, and decisions required. Notify District counsel promptly of significant preservation or litigation-sensitive issues.
C. Detailed Calculation Schedules. Provide an editable spreadsheet or other machine-readable analytical workpaper with transaction-to-summary traceability and separate schedules for (1) greens-fee revenue and rent, (2) operating profits and owner benefits, (3) annual maintenance and repair spending, (4) capital improvements and annual shortfalls, and (5) alternative assumptions directed by District counsel.
D. Draft Report. A confidential draft for factual-accuracy review by authorized District representatives and counsel. The consultant retains responsibility for objective findings and must distinguish verified facts, assumptions, estimates, findings, and matters requiring legal interpretation.
E. Final Report. A signed, clear, evidence-based report suitable for potential litigation use. It shall identify engagement scope and limitations, qualifications and independence, review period, records and interviews, methodology, analyses, annual and cumulative financial results, specific contract-linked findings, discrepancy calculations, supporting exhibits, missing records, unresolved matters, and recommended additional action.
F. Presentations and Expert Services. Present findings to authorized District representatives and counsel. If separately approved, provide expert disclosures, declarations, demonstratives, deposition and trial preparation, testimony, rebuttal analysis, and opinions limited to qualified, independently supported matters. Material findings must be traceable to identified records and calculations. The consultant shall state when a finding represents an estimate rather than a verified amount.
6. RECORD ACCESS, LEGAL COORDINATION, AND INFORMATION SECURITY
A. Record requests must be coordinated with the District. The audit-right and financial-reporting provisions in the governing agreements form part of the anticipated basis for access; the consultant has no independent authority to compel records outside lawful contractual or litigation processes.
B. The District may use the consultant initially as a non-testifying consulting expert, a testifying expert, or both as separately designated in writing. No communications, production, or designation shall be undertaken on the assumption that all work is privileged or protected.
C. Preserve original native data, file metadata, analytical scripts, versions, transformations, custody logs, and reproducible workpapers. Do not alter source records. Implement encryption, role-based access, secure transfer, incident reporting, and retention/destruction procedures to be defined in the contract.
D. All records held by the District are subject to applicable Washington public-records laws, including available exemptions. Neither the RFP nor a consultant contract may promise confidentiality contrary to law. Consultant shall consult District counsel before disclosure of litigation-sensitive material.
E. Consultant shall use independent professional judgment. District comments may correct facts or clarify legal assumptions, but shall not dictate findings or opinions.
7. PROJECT SCHEDULE
The District anticipates commencing promptly after contract execution, targeted for no later than January 4, 2027. The District's original target for substantial completion is April 2027, but respondents shall identify a feasible staged schedule based on the 2014-to-present review period, historical data availability and profit reconstruction. A final schedule will be established in the contract.
Required milestones. Contract/records matrix and preservation plan; initial financial/data availability assessment; preliminary greens-fee and rent analysis; profit and owner-benefit analysis; capital improvements and maintenance analysis; draft report; final report and presentations.
8. CONSULTANT QUALIFICATIONS
Responding firms must demonstrate meaningful experience in forensic accounting, commercial revenue-reconstruction engagements, financial investigations, analysis of business profits and related-party transactions, and litigation-support work. Experience with golf course operations, maintenance and capital-expenditure testing, or similar revenue-generating facilities is particularly valuable.
9. PROPOSAL CONTENT AND FEE FORMAT
Proposals shall be concise but substantive and organized in the following order:
1. Cover letter with primary contact, phone, email and website.
2. Firm overview and experience.
3. Key project personnel: Provide an engagement lead holding an active Washington CPA license and demonstrated forensic accounting expertise, preferably with the Certified Forensic Accountant (Cr.FA), Certified in Financial Forensics (CFF), Certified Public Accountant (CPA) with forensic accounting specialization, or equivalent credentialed professional. A Certified Fraud Examiner (CFE) or other qualified investigator may be included as appropriate; two separate credentialed individuals are not automatically required. Resume(s) for key personnel who will be assigned to this project; relevant credentials and litigation qualifications.
4. References: Provide three references from agencies or organizations to which the respondent has provided similar services and that PenMet Parks may contact.
5. Fee proposal: a. Provide an estimated not-to-exceed fee for each phase of the work. See Appendix A. b. Provide hourly rates for key personnel. c. Provide hourly rates for expert witness services, if requested and authorized by PenMet Parks. d. Identify any services that are recommended that are not included in the scope of work or fee proposal. Include a fee proposal for each recommended service or task.
EVALUATION AND SELECTION
PenMet Parks will evaluate proposals using the following criteria and may conduct interviews, request clarification, seek best and final proposals, check references, or award without further negotiations: Criterion Weight Relevant forensic accounting experience and qualifications 50% Ability to meet a feasible project schedule 20% Fee proposal 20% Potential expert witness experience 10%
PenMet Parks may reject any or all proposals, waive nonmaterial irregularities, and select the proposal determined most advantageous to the District, consistent with its applicable purchasing policies. Selection does not create a binding contract until execution of a written agreement.
11. PROPOSAL SUBMITTAL, QUESTIONS, AND RFP TIMELINE
Proposals and written questions shall be submitted electronically, in PDF format to: Jessica Wigle, Director of Finance jwigle@penmetparks.org
Unofficial oral statements are not binding. Contacts concerning this RFP with other PenMet Parks' representatives may result in disqualification. Proposals must be received by 5:00 p.m. Pacific Time on December 1, 2026; late proposals will not be considered.
RFP anticipated timeline: Activity Anticipated date RFP issued November 5, 2026 Written questions due Noon, November 16, 2026 Responses to questions posted Noon, November 19, 2026 Proposals due 5:00 p.m., December 1, 2026 Interviews if requested Week of December 7, 2026 Notice of intent to award December 14, 2026 Contract execution target No later than January 4, 2027
PenMet Parks reserves the right to modify the schedule by addendum posted at penmetparks.org. Respondents are responsible for reviewing published addenda and incorporating them into proposals.
12. STANDARD PROCUREMENT AND CONTRACT CONDITIONS
• REJECTION OF PROPOSALS: PenMet Parks reserves the right to reject any and all proposals and to waive irregularities and informalities in the submittal and evaluation process. This Request for Proposal does not obligate PenMet Parks to pay any costs incurred by respondents in the preparation and submission of a proposal. Furthermore, the Request for Proposals does not obligate PenMet Parks to accept or contract for any expressed or implied services.
• CONTRACT AWARD: PenMet Parks reserves the right to make an award without further discussion of the proposal submitted. Therefore, the proposal should be initially submitted in the most favorable light. PenMet Parks shall not be bound or in any way obligated until both parties have executed a written vendor contract. The respondent selected will be expected to enter into a contract with PenMet Parks.
• PAYMENT: All invoices related to the contract shall be paid by a PenMet Parks warrant usually within 30 days of PenMet Parks' receipt of a proper invoice and PenMet Parks approval of the respondent's completed tasks/deliverables to the date of the invoice or monthly report, as appropriate.
• EQUAL OPPORTUNITY EMPLOYMENT: The successful respondent must comply with PenMet Parks equal opportunity requirements. PenMet Parks is committed to a program of equal employment opportunity regardless of race, color, creed, sex, age, nationality, or disability.
• BACKGROUND CHECK: The successful respondent may be required to submit to a criminal background check. If a background check is required, the contract award shall be contingent upon PenMet Parks receipt of an acceptable background check report for any persons providing services or work under the agreement.
• INSURANCE REQUIREMENTS: The successful respondent shall maintain insurance that is sufficient to protect the respondent and PenMet Parks against all applicable risks.
• NON-ENDORSEMENT: As a result of the selection of a respondent to supply products and/or services to PenMet Parks, the successful respondent agrees to make no reference to PenMet Parks in any literature, promotional material, brochures, sales presentation, or the like without the express prior written consent of PenMet Parks.
• NON-COLLUSION: Submittal and signature of this Proposal swears that the Proposal is genuine and not a sham or collusive and not made in the interest of any person not named, and that the Firm has not induced or solicited others to submit a sham offer, or to refrain from proposing.
• COMPLIANCE WITH LAWS AND REGULATIONS: In addition to the nondiscrimination requirements previously listed, the successful respondent shall comply with all applicable federal, state, and local laws, statutes and ordinances relative to the execution of the work. This requirement includes, but is not limited to, protection of public and employee safety and health; environmental protection; waste reduction and recycling; the protection of natural resources; permits; fees; taxes; and similar subjects.
• PUBLIC RECORDS: Under Washington state law, the documents (including but not limited to written, printed, graphic, electronic, photographic or voice mail materials and/or transcriptions, recordings or reproductions thereof) submitted in response to this RFP (the "documents") become a public record upon submission to PenMet Parks, subject to mandatory disclosure upon request by any person, unless the documents are exempted from public disclosure by a specific provision of law. If PenMet Parks receives a request for inspection or copying of any such documents it will endeavor to notify the person submitting the documents to PenMet Parks (by U.S. mail or by e-mail if the person has provided an e-mail address, or by fax if the person has provided a fax number) and upon the written request of such person, received by PenMet Parks within five (5) calendar days of the mailing of such notice, will postpone disclosure of the documents for a reasonable period of time as permitted by law to enable such person to seek a court order prohibiting or conditioning the release of the documents. PenMet Parks assumes no contractual obligation to enforce any exemption nor any contractual obligation to provide such notice.
APPENDIX A - REQUIRED FEE SCHEDULE
Quote labor by phase and role, expected hours, rates, outside costs, assumptions, and a phase not-to-exceed amount. The District may authorize phases in sequence and is not committed to purchasing optional services.
Phase / service Not-to-exceed fee (respondent enters) I. Contract/risk assessment; records and work plan _____________________ II. Greens-fee reconstruction and rent reconciliation _____________________ III. Full operating results, owner benefits and reasonable _____________________ profit IV. Maintenance, repair and capital-improvement _____________________ analysis V. Authorized interviews and corroboration _____________________ Final report, workpapers, briefing _____________________ Total mandatory base proposal _____________________ OPTION: Additional historical or expanded fraud testing Hourly rate / separate written proposal OPTION: Consulting-expert / deposition / trial support Hourly rate(s) / separate authorization
Identify excluded tasks, estimated reimbursable expenses, any data-conversion or software charges, proposed subcontractor arrangements, the cost of optional conditions work, and the pricing effect of record gaps or delayed document access. Expert witness services shall be separately priced and authorized.
END OF RFP